Turabian vs Chicago: What Is Actually Different
Turabian vs Chicago is a confusing comparison, because the answer is both simple and easy to misstate. For citations, the two styles are essentially the same. For the manuals themselves, they are different books, for different readers, with different lengths, different paper formatting guidance, and now, different editions. If your tutor says Turabian, and you use Chicago, you will usually get the citations right. If your tutor says Chicago 18th edition, and you use Turabian 9th edition, you may be using an older edition without realising it.
This guide explains the difference in plain terms, with the same book shown in both systems, and with the edition gap stated clearly, so you can choose correctly for your assignment.
Table of Contents
Turabian vs Chicago: the short answer
Turabian is the student version of Chicago. It is based on Kate L. Turabian, A Manual for Writers of Research Papers, Theses, and Dissertations, 9th edition, published in 2018, which corresponds to the 17th edition of The Chicago Manual of Style, published in 2017. Chicago itself is the full manual for writers, editors, and publishers, now in its 18th edition, published on 19 September 2024.
Prairie View A&M University Library puts the relationship in one sentence that is worth remembering: except for a few minor differences, the citation style is the same as Chicago style, in the 17th edition, while the main difference is that Chicago focuses on publishing, and Turabian focuses on the creation and submission of academic work.
That is why library guides from Prairie View A&M, Trinity Western, Florida Gulf Coast, and James Cook all repeat the same point, in different words: Turabian is a pared down, student friendly version of Chicago, and a citation in Chicago style is also a citation in Turabian style, for the editions that align.
- Prairie View A&M University Library, Introduction to Turabian and Chicago Style
- James Cook University Library, Chicago 18th, including Chicago vs Turabian
- Trinity Western University Library, Chicago and Turabian
Turabian vs Chicago: 4 differences that matter
Most online lists invent citation differences that do not exist. The real differences are about audience, scope, paper formatting, and editions. Those four are the ones that change what you should do.
1. Audience. Turabian is written for students writing research papers, theses, and dissertations, especially in history, the humanities, and theology. Chicago is written for professional writers, editors, and publishers, as well as for students who need the full manual. If you are writing a thesis, Turabian is the natural starting point. If you are preparing a manuscript for publication, Chicago is the manual your publisher will expect.
2. Scope and length. Chicago is a comprehensive editorial reference. It covers grammar and usage, manuscript preparation, production, and publishing, as well as citations. Turabian omits much of that publishing detail, and instead gives guidance on research, writing, and submitting academic work. That makes Turabian shorter and easier to use for a student, but it also means Turabian will not answer a publishing question that Chicago does answer.
3. Paper formatting guidance. Turabian gives detailed guidance for student papers and theses: title pages, margins, headings, and the layout of a dissertation. Chicago gives minimal paper formatting guidance for students, because its readers are not usually submitting a thesis to a university. In practice, your university template overrides both manuals on paper formatting. If your department gives you a template, use it, even if it differs from Turabian or Chicago on a margin or a heading.
4. Edition gap. This is the difference that matters most in 2026, and it is the one most guides gloss over. Turabian 9th edition, 2018, aligns with Chicago 17th edition, 2017. Chicago 18th edition came out in 2024. As of the library guides checked for this article, no new Turabian edition that incorporates Chicago 18 changes had been published yet. James Cook University Library notes that a new Turabian edition can be expected shortly, but that is an expectation, not a published book. Auckland University of Technology Library, in its Chicago guide, notes the same gap, and recommends using Chicago 18th edition rather than Turabian 9th edition at the moment, to avoid confusion.
That gap does not mean Turabian citations are suddenly wrong. For most student papers, the citation forms in Turabian 9 and Chicago 17 are the same as the forms in Chicago 18 for common source types. It does mean you should check your course requirement by edition, not just by name. If your course says Turabian 9, use Turabian 9. If it says Chicago 18, use Chicago 18, not Turabian 9 by assumption. If it just says Chicago, ask which edition, or check a recent library guide for your university.
| Element | Turabian 9th edition, 2018 | Chicago 18th edition, 2024 |
|---|---|---|
| Based on | Chicago 17th edition, 2017 | Full Chicago manual, revised in 2024 |
| Main reader | Students, theses and dissertations | Writers, editors, publishers, and students who need the full manual |
| Citation systems | Notes-bibliography and author-date, same as Chicago | Notes-bibliography and author-date |
| Paper formatting | Detailed student and thesis guidance | Minimal student paper guidance, publishing focus |
| What to check | Does your course name Turabian, or Chicago? | Does your course name Chicago 18, or an older edition? |
Turabian vs Chicago: the same book in both systems
Both Turabian and Chicago offer two citation systems. Notes-bibliography uses footnotes or endnotes, plus a bibliography. Author-date uses parenthetical citations in the text, plus a reference list. Do not mix the two systems in one paper. Choose the system your course asks for, and use it consistently.
Use one real book to see how the systems work, and how little Turabian and Chicago differ in citation form. The book is Daniel Kahneman, Thinking, Fast and Slow, published by Farrar, Straus and Giroux in 2011, ISBN 9780374275631, which was also used in the ISBN to citation guide on this site.
Notes-bibliography, first note:
- Daniel Kahneman, Thinking, Fast and Slow (New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2011), 45.
Notes-bibliography, shortened note, for a later citation to the same book:
- Kahneman, Thinking, Fast and Slow, 52.
Notes-bibliography, bibliography entry:
Kahneman, Daniel. Thinking, Fast and Slow. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2011.
Notice the differences between a note and a bibliography entry, which are the same in Turabian and Chicago. A note starts with the first name, puts publication details in parentheses, and ends with the page you used. A bibliography entry starts with the surname, puts publication details without parentheses, and gives no page, because it lists the whole book. A shortened note, used after the first full note, gives only the surname, a shortened title, and the page.
Author-date, in-text citation:
(Kahneman 2011, 45)
Author-date, reference list entry:
Kahneman, Daniel. 2011. Thinking, Fast and Slow. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
In author-date, the year follows the author name in the reference list, and the in-text citation gives author, year, and page, with no comma after the author in the usual Chicago form. That pattern is the same in Turabian author-date and Chicago author-date, for the editions that align.
Experience note: when students get Turabian wrong, it is rarely because they chose Turabian instead of Chicago. It is usually because they mixed notes-bibliography with author-date, or because they used a bibliography entry as a footnote, or a footnote as a bibliography entry. Check which system you are in, then check whether the entry you are writing is a note or a bibliography entry. That one check fixes most Turabian and Chicago errors, in my experience checking student lists against library guides.
Choosing between Turabian and Chicago
Follow your course, in this order. First, use the style and edition your course or department names. If it names Turabian 9, use Turabian 9. If it names Chicago 18, use Chicago 18. Second, if it names only Chicago, with no edition, check your university library guide for the edition it currently teaches, and check whether it warns about the Turabian 9 and Chicago 18 gap. Third, if it names only Turabian, with no edition, assume Turabian 9, since that is the current edition, but check the library guide to confirm.
For a thesis or dissertation, Turabian is usually the better starting point, because its paper formatting guidance is written for that task. For a journal article or a book manuscript, Chicago is usually the better starting point, because its guidance is written for publication. For a short undergraduate essay, either manual will give you the same citation forms, provided the editions align, so the choice matters less than consistency.
Use the free generator on this site at https://citationgenerator.dev/ to draft Chicago and Turabian references, then check the output against the system you chose, notes-bibliography or author-date, and against the edition your course requires. A generator that gives you a bibliography entry when you needed a note has not failed on style. It has given you the wrong part of the style, and that is a check worth doing by hand.
FAQS
Is Turabian the same as Chicago?
For citations, essentially yes, for the editions that align. Turabian 9th edition corresponds to Chicago 17th edition, with only minor differences in citation style. For the manuals as a whole, no. Turabian is shorter, student focused, and gives thesis formatting guidance. Chicago is longer, publishing focused, and now in its 18th edition, while Turabian is still in its 9th edition.
Which Chicago edition does Turabian follow?
Turabian 9th edition, 2018, follows Chicago 17th edition, 2017. Chicago 18th edition came out in 2024, and as of the library guides checked for this article, no new Turabian edition incorporating Chicago 18 changes had been published yet. Check your course requirement by edition, not just by name.
Does Turabian use ibid?
Older Chicago and Turabian guidance used ibid. for a repeated note immediately following the same source. Current Chicago 17th and 18th edition guidance, and Turabian 9th edition guidance as taught by most library guides, prefers shortened notes instead of ibid., for clarity and for electronic documents where notes can move. If your course still asks for ibid., follow your course, but do not assume ibid. is the current default.
Is Turabian only for students?
Turabian was written for students, and it is most commonly used for undergraduate papers, theses, and dissertations, especially in history, the humanities, and theology. That does not mean a professional writer cannot use it, but Chicago is the manual publishers expect. Use the manual your reader, course, or publisher names.
Should I use notes-bibliography or author-date?
Use the system your course or journal asks for. Notes-bibliography is common in history and the humanities, and uses footnotes or endnotes plus a bibliography. Author-date is common in the sciences and social sciences, and uses parenthetical citations plus a reference list. Do not mix the two in one paper, and do not use a note where a bibliography entry belongs, or vice versa.