Reference List vs Bibliography: 5 Key Differences Made Easy
Reference list vs bibliography is a question that sounds simple, and stays confusing, because different styles use the same words to mean different things. In one style, a list headed Bibliography contains only cited works. In another style, a list headed Bibliography contains cited works plus background reading. In a third style, the list is not called a bibliography at all.
This guide gives 5 differences that actually decide what to submit, by style, with a table you can check against your course guide, rather than a single definition that fits one style and fails the next.
Table of Contents
Reference list vs bibliography: the core test
The core test is simple: does the list contain only sources cited in the text, or does it also contain sources you read but did not cite?
A reference list, in the strict sense, contains only sources cited in the text. Every entry matches an in-text citation, and every in-text citation matches an entry. A bibliography, in the broad sense, contains sources you used, which can include background reading that shaped your work but never appears as a citation. That broad sense is the traditional meaning of bibliography, and it is still used in some departments and in some Chicago and Turabian contexts, where a bibliography can include works consulted as well as works cited.
The complication is that many lists called Bibliography in practice contain only cited works, just under a different heading. Chicago notes-bibliography, for example, pairs footnotes with a Bibliography that usually contains the same works as the notes, not a separate set of background reading, unless your course asks for consulted works as well. So the heading alone does not tell you the rule. The style, and your course guide, do.
Reference list vs bibliography: 5 key differences
Difference 1: What the list contains
A reference list contains cited works only. A bibliography, in its broad form, contains cited works plus consulted works. If your course asks for a bibliography and does not specify, ask whether consulted works should be included, because that one choice changes the whole list. If you add consulted works to an APA References list, you have broken the APA matching rule. If you leave consulted works out of a bibliography that asked for them, you have left out reading your course wanted to see.
Difference 2: Which heading each style uses
APA uses References. MLA uses Works Cited, with an optional Works Consulted list for uncited material, kept separate from Works Cited. Chicago notes-bibliography uses Bibliography. Chicago author-date uses References. Harvard, Cite Them Right, uses Reference list, although Harvard is a family of university variants, and some departments say Bibliography for a wider list. Vancouver and AMA, as numbered styles, use a reference list in order of first citation, not alphabetical order, which is a separate difference from the heading.
Do not change a heading to match a word you prefer. A paper in APA with a heading Bibliography, or a paper in MLA with a heading References, signals to a marker that the style was not followed, even if the entries themselves are correct.
Difference 3: How the list links to the text
In an author-date style, such as APA or Harvard, each entry links to a parenthetical or narrative citation in the text, by author and year. In MLA, each entry links to a parenthetical citation by author and page. In Chicago notes-bibliography, each entry links to a footnote or endnote, which gives a full note on first citation and a shortened note later, plus a bibliography entry at the end. In a numbered style, such as Vancouver or AMA, each entry links to a number in the text, in order of first use.
That link is why a reference list cannot contain uncited works in APA, MLA, or Harvard: there would be no citation to link to. A bibliography in Chicago notes-bibliography can contain consulted works, because the link is looser: the bibliography is a list of works used, not only works cited in a note, in the broad form, and your course guide decides whether that broader form applies.
Difference 4: Order and form
Most alphabetical lists, in APA, MLA, Chicago, Harvard, and Turabian, are ordered by author surname, or by title if there is no author. Numbered lists, in Vancouver and AMA, are ordered by first citation in the text, not alphabetically. That order difference matters more than the heading difference, because a numbered list in alphabetical order, or an alphabetical list in citation order, is wrong in both styles, even if every entry is otherwise correct.
Form also differs by style, not by the words reference list or bibliography. APA entries use sentence case for book and article titles, with initials for authors, and a hanging indent. MLA entries use title case for book and article titles, with full first names where available, and a hanging indent. Chicago bibliography entries use title case, with full names, and a hanging indent, but with different punctuation from APA and MLA. Do not copy form from one style into another just because both lists are at the end of a paper.
Difference 5: What happens if you get it wrong
If you submit a bibliography where a reference list was asked for, and you include uncited works, a marker in APA or MLA will see extra entries with no matching citations, and will mark them as errors, not as extra reading. If you submit a reference list where a bibliography was asked for, and you leave out consulted works your course wanted, a marker may see a narrow research base, even if every cited entry is correct. If you submit both lists, with a reference list first and a bibliography second, as some courses ask for, make sure the two lists do not duplicate the same works in a confusing way: the reference list holds cited works, the bibliography holds the extra reading, and the headings make that split clear.
Reference list vs bibliography: a table by style
| Style | List heading | Contains uncited reading? | Order |
|---|---|---|---|
| APA 7 | References | No, cited works only | Alphabetical by author |
| MLA 9 | Works Cited | No, cited works only, Works Consulted separate if asked | Alphabetical by author |
| Chicago, notes-bibliography | Bibliography | Usually cited works, consulted works only if course asks | Alphabetical by author |
| Chicago, author-date | References | No, cited works only | Alphabetical by author |
| Harvard, Cite Them Right | Reference list | Usually no, check university guide | Alphabetical by author |
| Vancouver | References, numbered | No, cited works only | Order of first citation |
| AMA 11 | References, numbered | No, cited works only | Order of first citation |
Use that table as a starting point, not as a substitute for your course guide. If your course guide says something different from the table, follow your course guide, because Harvard variants, Chicago departments, and journal instructions all differ from the general pattern in specific cases.
Reference list vs bibliography: a worked check
Use the same two sources to test the difference. First, a book you cited: Kahneman, D. (2011), Thinking, Fast and Slow, Farrar, Straus and Giroux. Second, a book you read for background but did not cite: Orwell, G. (1949), 1984, Secker and Warburg.
In an APA References list, include Kahneman only, because only Kahneman was cited. In an MLA Works Cited list, include Kahneman only, for the same reason. In a Chicago notes-bibliography Bibliography that asks for works consulted as well as works cited, include both Kahneman and Orwell, with Orwell listed as a consulted work, if your course asks for that form, and make sure the distinction is clear in your own notes, even if the printed list does not label it. In a Chicago notes-bibliography Bibliography that asks for cited works only, include Kahneman only.
That worked check is the fastest way to decide what to submit: list what you cited, list what you read but did not cite, and check your course guide for which of those two lists it wants, under which heading.
Outbound sources for this guide:
FAQS
Is a Works Cited page a reference list?
In function, yes. Works Cited is the MLA name for a list of cited sources, which is what a reference list means in APA and Harvard. The difference is the heading, and the entry format, not the basic idea: both lists contain only sources cited in the text, unless a separate Works Consulted list is asked for.
Can a bibliography contain sources I did not cite?
In the broad sense, yes, if your course or department asks for works consulted as well as works cited. In the narrow sense used by many Chicago courses, no, a bibliography contains only the works cited in notes, under the heading Bibliography. Check your course guide for which sense applies, rather than assuming from the heading alone.
What if my course asks for both a reference list and a bibliography?
Put the reference list first, with cited works only, then the bibliography second, with extra reading, and label both headings clearly. Do not duplicate the same works in both lists without a reason, because duplication looks like an error, not like extra reading, unless your course explicitly asks for that duplication.
Does a bibliography always go at the end?
Yes, in the usual form, at the end of the paper, before appendices if there are any, in alphabetical order for most styles, or in citation order for numbered styles. A bibliography is not a footnote, and it is not an introduction, even if it contains background reading.
Which list should I submit if my course does not say?
Follow the style your course names. If it names APA, submit References, cited works only. If it names MLA, submit Works Cited, cited works only. If it names Chicago notes-bibliography, submit Bibliography, and ask whether consulted works should be included, because that is the one case where the answer is not fixed by the style name alone.