Free Citation Generator — No Signup

AMA vs Vancouver: 5 Key Differences With Best Examples

AMA and Vancouver look almost identical at first glance. Both use numbers in the text. Both list references in the order they first appear. Both abbreviate journal titles. That similarity is exactly why they get mixed up, and why a manuscript formatted in one style can be returned for correction in the other.

The short answer is that AMA is a Vancouver style in the broad sense, and a different style in the narrow sense. AMA grew out of the Vancouver tradition, and it is used by JAMA and other American Medical Association publications. Vancouver, in the narrow sense, means the ICMJE Recommendations and the NLM Citing Medicine system used by many biomedical journals outside the AMA group. The differences are small, mechanical, and easy to miss. They are also the differences a typesetter will spot first.

AMA vs Vancouver: the differences at a glance

DifferenceAMA 11th editionVancouver, ICMJE and NLM
In-text numberSuperscript, placed after punctuation, for example results.1In the ICMJE text, a number in parentheses, for example results (1). Many Vancouver journals and universities instead use brackets [1] or superscripts, so check the target journal
Journal titleAbbreviated from the NLM Catalog, and italicisedAbbreviated from the NLM Catalog, usually in roman type, not italicised
Authors, more than 6List the first 3, then et al.List the first 6, then et al.
Authors, 6 or fewerList all authors, in both stylesList all authors, in both styles
Book placeNo place of publication in AMA 11 book referencesPlace of publication is still given in Vancouver books
Page range styleHyphen in many AMA examples, for example 869-75En dash in NLM examples, for example 869-75 in plain text, with shortened ending numbers in both styles where the journal asks for it
DOI formdoi:10.xxxx, with no period after a DOI or URL at the end of an entrydoi: 10.xxxx in NLM samples, with a space after the colon, and journal practice varies

The author cutoff is the cleanest mechanical difference, and it is worth checking in a university library guide rather than trusting a converter. Guides from New York Medical College, the University of Nebraska Medical Center, the University of Northern Colorado, and James Cook University all state the same AMA 11 rule: list all authors up to 6, and for more than 6, list the first 3 followed by et al. Vancouver, in the common ICMJE and NLM samples, lists the first 6 followed by et al. A seven author paper therefore looks different in the two styles, even when everything else matches.

AMA vs Vancouver: the same journal article in both styles

Use one real journal article to see the differences without the noise of different sources. The article below has a single author, so the author cutoff does not hide the other differences.

AMA 11th edition:

  1. Iacobellis G. COVID-19 and diabetes: can DPP4 inhibition play a role? Diabetes Res Clin Pract. 2020;162:108125. doi:10.1016/j.diabres.2020.108125

Vancouver, NLM style:

  1. Iacobellis G. COVID-19 and diabetes: can DPP4 inhibition play a role? Diabetes Res Clin Pract. 2020;162:108125. doi: 10.1016/j.diabres.2020.108125

The visible difference in the two entries above is the journal title. AMA italicises Diabetes Res Clin Pract. Vancouver leaves it in roman type. The DOI spacing differs too: AMA uses doi:10.xxxx with no space, while NLM Vancouver samples use doi: 10.xxxx with a space. Neither difference changes the source. Both will cause a correction if the journal expects the other form.

The author cutoff shows up separately, in papers with seven or more authors. As a pattern, not a real paper, AMA gives: Author1, Author2, Author3, et al. Vancouver, under the common rule, gives: Author1, Author2, Author3, Author4, Author5, Author6, et al. That is the point to check when you convert: do not copy an AMA author list into a Vancouver manuscript and assume the cutoff is the same.

For a book, the difference is larger. AMA 11 does not require a place of publication. Vancouver still gives one.

AMA 11 book:

Orwell G. 1984. Secker & Warburg; 1949.

Vancouver book:

Orwell G. 1984. London: Secker & Warburg; 1949.

That book example is simplified, to show the place difference clearly. A full AMA or Vancouver book entry would also need edition details where relevant, and a chapter entry would need chapter authors, chapter title, book editors, and page range. The place rule is the point here, not the full book template.

AMA and Vancouver: same family, different style

No, not in the narrow sense, and yes, in the broad sense. That split causes most of the confusion.

In the broad sense, Vancouver means any numbered, citation-sequence style that grew out of the 1978 Vancouver meeting of medical journal editors. AMA belongs to that family, along with many journal house styles. In that broad sense, calling AMA a Vancouver style is not wrong.

In the narrow sense, Vancouver means the ICMJE Recommendations and NLM Citing Medicine. AMA is a separate manual, the AMA Manual of Style, 11th edition, with its own rules for superscripts, italics, author cutoff, and book place. A journal that asks for Vancouver in the narrow sense will not accept an AMA list without changes, and a JAMA Network journal that asks for AMA will not accept a Vancouver list without changes.

The practical rule is simple. Do not choose by family name. Choose by the target journal or course guide. If the guide says AMA 11th edition, use superscripts, italic journal titles, first 3 plus et al. after 6, and no book place. If the guide says Vancouver, ICMJE, or NLM, use the in-text mark that guide specifies, roman journal titles, first 6 plus et al., and a book place. If the guide just says Vancouver, with no further detail, check a recent issue of the target journal. Many journals that say Vancouver use brackets or superscripts in practice, even though the ICMJE text uses parentheses.

AMA vs Vancouver: how to choose for your journal

Start with the journal instructions, not with a converter label. A converter labelled Vancouver may produce brackets, parentheses, or superscripts, depending on its template. A converter labelled AMA may produce a Vancouver author cutoff if its template is wrong. Check the output against the four points below, in order.

First, check the in-text mark. AMA wants superscripts after punctuation. Vancouver, in the ICMJE text, wants parentheses. A Vancouver journal in practice may want brackets. The mark in your text must match the journal, not the converter default.

Second, check the journal title. AMA italicises the abbreviated title. Vancouver, in NLM samples, does not. This is the fastest visual check in a reference list, and it is worth doing on every entry, not just the first one.

Third, check the author cutoff. Count the authors in a paper with seven or more authors. AMA should show three names plus et al. Vancouver should show six names plus et al. If your list shows the wrong count, change the output style or fix the entry by hand, rather than leaving it and hoping a reviewer will not notice.

Fourth, check books. AMA 11 books have no place. Vancouver books have a place. If your list mixes the two, with some books showing a place and others not, that inconsistency alone signals a style mix-up.

One more difference matters for JAMA Network journals specifically. AMA guides note a required issue number in JAMA Network journal articles, where a volume alone is not enough. Vancouver samples also give volume and issue in the usual pattern, but a JAMA submission that omits the issue number will be flagged. Check the journal instructions for that detail, rather than assuming a volume-only entry is safe.

Common mistakes when switching between AMA and Vancouver

A common mistake is to change only the in-text numbers. A student who moves a paper from a Vancouver course to a JAMA style journal may change brackets to superscripts, and leave the journal titles in roman type, the author lists at six plus et al., and the book places in place. The text then looks AMA, and the list does not.

The reverse mistake is just as common. A Vancouver manuscript built from an AMA template will have italic journal titles, first 3 plus et al. author lists, and books with no place. A reviewer who knows Vancouver will spot the italics first, then the author cutoff.

Another mistake is to treat page ranges and DOI spacing as unimportant. They are small, but they are part of the style. AMA uses a hyphen in page ranges in many examples, and no period after a DOI or URL at the end of an entry, so the link stays clickable. NLM Vancouver samples use an en dash for page ranges in print, and a space after doi:. If your journal uses a reference manager style, let the style handle those details, then check one entry by hand.

Finally, do not assume that a reference manager style named Vancouver matches your journal. There are many Vancouver variants in Zotero, EndNote, and Mendeley, with different in-text marks and different italics settings. Choose the variant that matches your journal, or edit the style, and check the output against the journal instructions before you submit. For the related APA to Vancouver conversion, including NLM journal abbreviations and renumbering, see Convert APA to Vancouver.

FAQS

Is JAMA Vancouver or AMA?

JAMA is AMA. The Journal of the American Medical Association and other AMA publications use the AMA Manual of Style, currently the 11th edition. Do not submit a Vancouver list to JAMA without converting it to AMA, including superscripts, italic journal titles, and the author cutoff above.

Do AMA and Vancouver use italics?

AMA italicises abbreviated journal titles and book titles. Article titles are not italicised. Vancouver, in NLM samples, usually leaves journal titles in roman type. Book titles in Vancouver are also not italicised in NLM samples, although some Vancouver journals and university guides differ. Check the target journal for its italics rule.

How many authors do AMA and Vancouver list?

Both list all authors up to 6. For more than 6 authors, AMA lists the first 3 followed by et al., while Vancouver, in the common ICMJE and NLM pattern, lists the first 6 followed by et al. That difference only shows up in papers with seven or more authors, which is why it is easy to miss in a short list.

Does AMA use superscript or brackets?

AMA uses superscripts, placed after punctuation. Vancouver, in the ICMJE text, uses numbers in parentheses. Many Vancouver journals and universities use brackets or superscripts in practice, so a Vancouver in-text mark is not fixed in the same way as AMA. Check the target journal.

Can I convert AMA to Vancouver with a converter?

Yes, as a first draft, but check the four points in the choice section above: in-text mark, journal title italics, author cutoff, and book place. A converter that only changes the in-text mark has not converted the list. A reference manager style change, from AMA 11th edition to a Vancouver variant that matches your journal, is usually safer than a text converter, because it updates the whole list at once.

Back to all articles